Rocafella's Pizza A Taste of New York

Reviews about Rocafella's Pizza A Taste of New York

• 1 / 5

  By Carissa King
  This was the 1st time I placed a order and will be the last. I ordered a small pizza (cold) chicken wings well done (cold) and a salad that is supposed too be cold but was pulled out of the same bag as the pizza and wings. (thought the bag was to help food stay warm) anyway my salad was slimy brown and wilted
  The "supervisor" said "I don't blame you if you wouldn't want to eat it again" talking about the salad. He offered me a credit for it but I rather not. I don't normally write reviews but this is just gross.
  February 18, 2017
• 5 / 5

  By Tiff J
  This is hands down our favorite pizza joint! Not only is their pizza the best, but we often add on a side of blackened wings with the sweet red chili sauce. Sometimes we even go for just the wings because we love that they aren't fried. All the guys working have always been extremely friendly and welcoming. They definitely have our business for life.
  August 31, 2016
• 5 / 5

  By Roy Reynolds
  Great little pizza joint. Super nice staff. Walked this out of towner through the menu and made great suggestions. The pizza crust was crisp and perfectly cooked. Great bread sticks.
  August 16, 2016
• 4 / 5

  By Jason H.
  Of course, I'm going to preface this with my standard Pizza Place prologue. I am from Chicago originally and I am a pizza snob. So if it's not in Chicago, I have to take it with a grain of salt but then again I won't hold it against a place.
  
  This place was pretty good. Very friendly guys working there, nice pizza place atmosphere. Very basic but exactly what they say they are. A pizza place.
  
  We ordered some of the hot wings. They make grilled wings and they are fresh and pretty tasty. They're different. They're not like everybody else's wings. I would give them a try. I would definitely have them again.
  
  I had a supreme, I think it was supreme, pizza. Pepperoni, sausage, green pepper, onions I think. It was good. Again, not great, but really good. I did enjoy it. Nice crispy thin crust and good ingredients. And that's what really matters. These guys do you use good ingredients. The only ingredient I was disappointed with was the Italian sausage. Didn't taste like freshly cooked Italian sausage. Kind of the roundish Italian sausage balls that you would get from a place like Little Caesars. Other than that, good pizza.
  
  Would I go back? Yeah. I would. Unfortunately Cincinnati is engulfed in LaRosa's, Papa John's and the other crap chains. So, I like to try little one off local places. That's where, in my opinion, you usually find the best pizzas in Cincinnati. Check out your local pizza places, I guarantee you, it'll be worth it.
  June 23, 2016